Start here. White has two checks in this position, one with the bishop on b3 and one with the rook on d1, and exactly one of them is mate.
7
2
d
g 1.Bxf7+ is the check most people see first, because a capture with check feels like progress. Count the king’s squares afterwards: he takes the bishop, Kxf7, and White has thrown away a piece for nothing.
1.Rd8 gives no material, takes nothing, and wins on the spot. The rook covers the whole eighth rank, so f8 and h8 are gone; f7, g7 and h7 belong to Black’s own pawns; nothing on the board attacks d8; there is no square between d8 and g8 to block on. That is a mate.
The method, in three questions
Find every check first. All of them, including the ones that hang a queen, before you evaluate any of them. Write them down if you are training. In the position above the list runs to two, Bxf7+ and Rd8; in a normal middlegame it is usually three or four, which is a small enough list to be honest about.
Then for each check in turn:
- How many squares can the king move to? Count them out loud if you can, and remember that a square occupied by his own piece is as good as a covered square for your purposes.
- Can anything capture the checking piece? Include the king himself, which means asking whether your checking piece is defended.
- Can anything get in between? Only applies to checks by a rook, bishop or queen along a line. A knight check can never be blocked.
Three noes means mate. One yes means move on to the next check. This is slower than intuition for about a week and then it stops being slow at all.
Question two is where the mates hide
Here is the same drill with the answer sitting behind the second question, and this time both checks land on the seventh rank.
7
6
2
g Two checks again: 1.Qxh7+ and 1.Qxg7. They look almost identical. The first loses the queen to 1…Kxh7, because nothing defends h7. The second is mate, because the bishop on b2 stares down the long diagonal to g7 and the king cannot take. After 1.Qxg7 the king’s remaining squares are f8 and h8, both covered by the queen from g7, and f7 and h7 hold his own pawns.
Same shape, g7 and h7 one square apart, opposite results. The question that separated them was not “is this a check” but “who is defending the square I am landing on”.
Drilling it
Do them in volume and at speed. Twenty mate-in-one puzzles a day for two weeks will change how quickly you see the end of a line, and the patterns you meet there, the back rank above all, are the same ones that decide your own games. When a one-mover takes you more than a few seconds, stop and work out which of the three questions you skipped.