Basic checkmates

Smothered mate explained simply

Updated · Sergei Tovmasian

Short answer

A smothered mate is checkmate by a knight against a king whose own pieces occupy every square around it. Only a knight can do it, because it is the one piece that jumps over the wall. The famous forcing version, Philidor's legacy, ends with a queen sacrifice that makes the defender block the king's last square.

This is the whole idea in one picture. The black king on h8 is checked by a knight on f7, and he is surrounded by his own furniture: rook on g8, pawns on g7 and h7.

8
7
6
5
4
3
2
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h 1
White plays Nf7 and it is mate. The king's three squares are all taken by his own pieces, and nothing attacks f7.

Notice what is not happening. Nobody blocks, because there is never a square between a knight and the king it checks. Nobody captures, because the rook on g8 does not see f7 and the king cannot reach it. Black is up a queen on a5 and it is completely irrelevant.

That is a smothered mate: a knight, a boxed-in king, and no way out. The knight is the only piece in chess that can deliver it, for the same reason it is the only piece that jumps over other pieces.

Philidor’s legacy: forcing the box shut

In the diagram above the rook was already on g8. In a real game it is on e8 or f8, and the beautiful part is that you can make Black put it there himself. The sequence has a name, Philidor’s legacy, and it goes like this.

8
7
6
5
4
3
2
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h 1
White to play: 1.Qe6+ Kh8 2.Nf7+ Kg8 3.Nh6+ Kh8 4.Qg8+ Rxg8 5.Nf7 mate. The rook is forced to fill the king's last square.

Walk it through. 1.Qe6+ hits the king along the diagonal and he must go to h8, because 1…Kf8 runs into 2.Qf7 mate with the knight on g5 guarding the queen.

2.Nf7+ Kg8 is a check the king can only answer by stepping back. Then 3.Nh6+ is the move that does the work: it is a double check, from the knight on h6 and from the queen on e6 down the diagonal that the knight has just vacated. A double check cannot be blocked and cannot be met by a capture, so 3…Kh8 is forced.

4.Qg8+ is the sacrifice. The queen puts herself where the rook must take her, and 4…Rxg8 is Black’s only legal move. Now the rook is standing on g8, the king’s last square, and 5.Nf7 is mate.

Where you will actually meet it

Look for it whenever an enemy king has castled short, its rook is still on f8 or e8, and you have a knight that can reach e5 or g5 with a queen on the a2 to g8 diagonal. Those three ingredients are the trigger. In my own games it has come up perhaps a dozen times in twenty years, always in the same shape.

Even when the full combination is not there, half of it often is, and a knight check that forces a king to shuffle can win a tempo you need for something else. Run a set of smothered mate puzzles until the shape is automatic, then compare it with the back-rank mate, which is the same crime committed by pawns instead of pieces.

More questions

Why can only a knight give a smothered mate?

Because the king is surrounded by its own pieces, so any other attacker would have to pass through them to reach him. The knight jumps, so the wall that traps the king does nothing to stop the check. That is also why the defender cannot block: there is no square between a knight and the king it is checking.

What is Philidor's legacy?

It is the name of the forcing sequence that produces a smothered mate: a queen check drives the king to the corner, the knight checks twice to shuffle him back and forth, and then the queen is sacrificed on g8 so that the defending rook is forced to occupy the king's last escape square. The knight then delivers mate on f7.

How do you defend against a smothered mate?

Give the king air before the knight arrives. A pawn move like h6 or g6 opens a square the knight cannot cover, and moving the rook off f8 or g8 means it can no longer be forced to block. Once the double check comes it is usually too late, because a double check can only be answered by a king move.

Go deeper

Practise these mates on real positions. The app serves thousands, matched to your rating.

← All: Basic checkmates · Learn chess